Mr. Gatti's Pizza Reviews
Mr. Gatti's Pizza has an overall rating of 4.7 based on 115 reviews. Customer feedback on Mr. Gatti's Pizza is mixed: Mr. Gatti's Pizza reviewers highlight positive aspects like delicious pizza, friendly staff, quick service, great value for money, which strongly appeal to families, pizza lovers, local residents, casual diners. However, Mr. Gatti's Pizza is often criticized for its limited seating, inconsistent delivery times, higher prices for specialty items, occasional long wait during peak hours.
115 reviews
5 Stars
24
4 Stars
1
3 Stars
2
2 Stars
1
1 Star
0
How would you rate Mr. Gatti's Pizza?
All Mr. Gatti's Pizza Reviews (115)
KathleenFulkerson_38
May 23, 2026
"Fun Spot for the Kids"
The game room was clean, fun, and kept the kids busy the whole time, which is always a win. The pizza was good too. We had a great time and will definitely be back soon.
0
Reply
hello_robert948
May 18, 2026
"Pizza was decent. Good choices there. But…"
Pizza was decent. Good choices there. But the salad? Not much going on. Dessert too. Felt kind of limited this time.
0
Reply
Mable_martinez75
May 09, 2026
"Hot and Fresh Delivery"
I ordered from Mr Gatti’s and the pizza showed up still really hot, which was great. The cheese was melted nicely and the crust was not soggy or cold like I have had from some other places. Even the breadsticks were still warm. It is a simple thing, but it really makes a difference. I would definitely order again.
0
Reply
ShanaPaider_95
May 06, 2026
"Fast and Hot Delivery"
I ordered from Mr Gatti’s the wait was way shorter than I thought it would be. The food showed up hot too, which always makes a big difference. If this order is anything to go by, they seem reliable
0
Reply
joan1986
April 30, 2026
"I was kind of in a…"
I was kind of in a rush and, i get impatient when I’m hungry, but they kept bringing out fresh pizza so fast that I never had to stand around waiting. Made the whole thing way easier for me.
0
Reply
hello_james559
April 24, 2026
"The kids loved it"
The kids had an absolute blast (it was fun just watching them enjoy themselves so much). Definitely a great experience for the whole family.
0
Reply
SWEEZER
April 06, 2026
"Good pizza, but the prizes were disappointing"
We mainly went to Mr. Gatti’s because my kids love the games. They had fun playing, but when it was time to pick prizes, the selection was disappointing. A lot of the shelves were empty, so there just weren’t many choices. Most of what was left were tiny cheap toys, and they cost way too many tickets. The pizza was okay, nothing special, but the weak prize counter really brought the visit down for the kids. Since we spent a decent amount, I expected a few better options. Hopefully they restock or update the prizes soon...
0
Reply
IvanBrewington_32
April 05, 2026
"Stopped by Mr Gatti’s Pizza and the place..."
Stopped by Mr Gatti’s Pizza and the place was super clean, which I always notice. Tables were wiped down, floors looked good, and even the bathrooms were decent not gross like some pizza places can be. Just made eating there feel way nicer
0
Reply
pat-Belland
April 05, 2026
"Grabbed some Mr Gatti’s Pizza it…"
Grabbed some Mr Gatti’s Pizza it was worth it. The pizza showed up hot, had a ton of cheese, and the deals made it way cheaper than I thought it’d be. It’s not some fancy spot or anything, but for a quick family dinner, it totally gets the job done. I’d definitely order again, no doubt.
0
Reply
hello_edith856
April 03, 2026
"Easy place to bring the kids"
We’ve been coming here with the kids and it’s always a stress-free choice. The staff is friendly, the pizza comes out fast, and it helps that there are usually other families around too, so we don’t feel like we’re the only ones with loud little ones. Just a solid, easy spot for a family meal
0
Reply
rita_Bryson72
April 02, 2026
"Loaded with toppings every time"
I’ve ordered from Mr Gatti’s a handful of times now, and one thing I really appreciate is how generous they are with the toppings. The pepperoni actually covers the pizza, the veggies are spread out evenly instead of piled in one spot, and there’s a solid layer of cheese all the way to the edges. It doesn’t feel like they’re skimping or just tossing on a few pieces for looks. For the price, I’ve been really happy with it because it feels like you’re getting exactly what you paid for.
0
Reply
hello_robert889
March 25, 2026
"Fun stop for pizza and games"
We went in mostly for pizza, but, you know, my kids pretty much made a beeline straight to the arcade. Most of the machines were working, and the screens and buttons looked clean, not all sticky and gross like you sometimes see at places like this. A couple of the games were a little older, but they still worked fine. The tickets came out like they were supposed to, and when one machine ate a token, the staff helped us quickly. Overall, it was a good visit
0
Reply
tracy_Lipton02
March 24, 2026
"Came for pizza, kept thinking about the salad bar"
I stopped in planning to just grab some pizza, but the salad bar ended up being my favorite part. Everything looked really fresh, the lettuce had that nice crisp bite, and they kept it stocked the whole time I was there. Funny how sometimes the simplest stuff is what you remember most, but yeah, it was just a really good, easy meal.
0
Reply
James-adams
March 22, 2026
"Decent crust, just a bit chewy"
The crust tasted fine overall, so I don’t think there was anything wrong with it, but it felt a little too chewy for me. Maybe that’s how it’s supposed to be? I just kept wondering if it was slightly overworked or underbaked. Flavor was okay, I’d just feel better if the texture was a bit lighter.
0
Reply
Latrice-richards
March 07, 2026
"Grabbed pizza from Mr. Gatti’s and…"
Grabbed pizza from Mr. Gatti’s and honestly??? It was way fresher than I thought it would be!! The crust was soft but not soggy, the cheese actually tasted good, and the toppings didn’t feel like they’d been sitting out forever... which I really appreciated. Even the salad stuff was crisp!!! That’s not always a given at pizza places, lol. Everything came out warm and fresh, so yeah... easy 5 stars from me!!
0
Reply
ROGERS
March 02, 2026
"Pretty solid delivery experience"
I ordered from Mr Gatti’s and the pizza showed up way faster than I was expecting. It was still hot too, which was kinda nice. The driver was polite and had no trouble finding my place. Overall, I was happy with it...
0
Reply
JudithThrift
February 27, 2026
"I thought it was going to be…"
I thought it was going to be more of a hassle to get, but it ended up being really easy. The whole process was straightforward, which was a nice surprise
0
Reply
JesusCassella
February 14, 2026
"Warm Cinnamon Goodness"
The cinnamon sticks showed up warm and sweet and they disappeared so fast because everyone kept grabbing one and then another before I could even think about saving any for later.
0
Reply
Ashton_medina96
February 14, 2026
"Surprisingly Fresh and Really Good"
I’m so tired of places acting like “fresh ingredients” is some huge selling point and then serving stuff that tastes like it’s been sitting around all day. But this was actually fresh and, to be fair, really good. No complaints there.
0
Reply
richardmikeska3486
February 14, 2026
"It was cheesy, hot, and the crust…"
It was cheesy, hot, and the crust was actually nice. Overall, I’d say it’s a good pick if you’re in the mood for something simple and satisfying.
0
Reply
Mr. Gatti's Pizza Q&A
Are the ecodes and percentages off apply to dine in customers?
0
Answer
Have a question about Mr. Gatti's Pizza?
Log in to ask your Mr. Gatti's Pizza question!
Customer Reviews
Questions & Answers
Ask a Question
